The judicial incompatibility clause - or, how a version of the 'Kable' principle nearly made it into the federal constitution

Taylor, G 2018, 'The judicial incompatibility clause - or, how a version of the 'Kable' principle nearly made it into the federal constitution', Adelaide Law Review, vol. 38, no. 2, pp. 351-373.


Document type: Journal Article
Collection: Journal Articles

Title The judicial incompatibility clause - or, how a version of the 'Kable' principle nearly made it into the federal constitution
Author(s) Taylor, G
Year 2018
Journal name Adelaide Law Review
Volume number 38
Issue number 2
Start page 351
End page 373
Total pages 23
Publisher Adelaide Law Review Association
Abstract Until nearly the end of the Convention debates the draft Australian Constitution contained a provision that would have prevented judges from holding any federal executive office. The prohibition, removed only at the last minute, would have extended to all federal executive offices but was originally motivated by a desire to ensure that judges did not hold office as Vice-Regal stand-ins when a Governor-General was unavailable, as well as by the feud between Sir Samuel Way CJ and (Sir) Josiah Symon QC. The clause was eventually deleted, but not principally because of any reservations about the separation of judicial power; rather, it was thought difficult to be sure that other suitable stand-ins could always be found and problematic to limit the royal choice of representative. However, this interesting episode also shows that a majority of the Convention and of public commentators rejected the idea of judicially enforcing, as a constitutional imperative, the separation of judicial power from the executive. Presumably, while not rejecting the separation of powers itself, they would have rejected the judicial enforcement of that principle such as now has been established by case law and implication.
Subject Constitutional Law
Legal Institutions (incl. Courts and Justice Systems)
History and Philosophy of Law and Justice
Keyword(s) Australian Constitution
legal history
constitutional law
constitutional history
separation of powers
Sir J.A. Symon K.C.
Copyright notice ©
ISSN 0065-1915
Versions
Version Filter Type
Access Statistics: 4 Abstract Views  -  Detailed Statistics
Created: Thu, 06 Dec 2018, 10:39:00 EST by Catalyst Administrator
© 2014 RMIT Research Repository • Powered by Fez SoftwareContact us